04 December 2008

Historic Cork Brewery Beamish & Crawford will be closed in March by its new Owner Heineken

If you have waited for today's scandal from Ireland and wondered what it could be, you have to wait no longer. Here it is, with bad news from Cork.
It is not as large and significant as the scandals uncovered in previous days, but for an Irishman, and especially one who lives in the southern province of Munster, it is bad enough.

The giant international brewery group Heineken - originally a Dutch company - is to close the historic Beamish & Crawford brewery in Cork (photo above), which they recently acquired.

The closure is scheduled for next March and will also mean the loss of 120 local jobs in Ireland's second-largest city.
Production of the famous Beamish stout, which looks like Guinness but tastes better, will be transferred to one site at Heineken Ireland's brewery (formerly Murphy's Brewery) in Cork's Leitrim Street. Up to 40 employees from Beamish & Crawford will move to Heineken Ireland, while 120 others are losing their jobs.

In a statement Heineken Ireland has said today that it made the decision "following a review of both individual brewing operations with particular focus on capacity, expansion capability and future investment".

This is nonsense. The real reason is most likely the interest Heineken has in selling off the large Beamish & Crawford site in the city centre of Cork, which would be very lucrative for some new commercial development.

Heineken's Managing Director Gerrit van Loo said: "Retaining two breweries in Cork is not sustainable and the loss of so many jobs remains a sad but unavoidable outcome. We will do all we can to minimise the impact on people and the community. We have agreed comprehensive severance terms with the trade unions, we will provide outplacement support, including career counselling, job search training and pension advice to all departing staff."

This is a severe blow for Cork as a city, but even more so for the traditional culture and lifestyle in the south of Ireland.
While the other three provinces have long been dominated by the Dublin-brewed Guinness stout, Munster had always more diversity and choice in the beer market. Though Guinness is available here as well and has meanwhile a large share of the stout market, there were also the alternatives from Cork: Beamish and Murphy's. The latter has been taken over by Heineken years ago and became the core operation of Heineken Ireland. Ever since it has gradually lost its unique identity, character and special taste. Subsequently it also lost a lot of its market share and has become a real minority drink now, rarely to be found anywhere outside Cork city.

Until recently Beamish remained the only true alternative to the international beer giants, although it has been foreign-owned already since 1962.

The Beamish & Crawford brewery was founded in Cork city in 1792 by William Beamish and William Crawford. They purchased an existing brewery on a site in Cramer's Lane that had been producing beer at least since 1650, but probably began brewing already in the early 16th century. Which ever date one takes, it makes this brewery the oldest existing beer producer in Ireland, beating its arch rival Guinness by at least 109 years and perhaps even by 250.

The historic brewery is still situated on the same site in the heart of Cork's medieval city, close to the site of the city's South Gate. (The old Cramer's Lane is now South Main Street) .

Under Mssrs. Beamish and Crawford the brewery prospered, and by 1805 it had become the largest in Ireland and the third-largest in the United Kingdom as a whole, with an output of 100,000 barrels per annum, up from 12,000 barrels per annum in 1792.

In 1865 the brewery underwent a full modernisation programme. This cost the owners £ 100,000 (which was a huge fortune at a time when middle-class people could live comfortably on £ 100 a year).

Alfred Barnard, a renowned brewing and distilling historian, remarked in his book Noted Breweries of Great Britain & Ireland in 1889 that: "The business of Beamish & Crawford in Cork is a very old one, dating as far back as the seventeenth century, and it is said to be the most ancient porter brewery in Ireland".

The company went public in 1901 and issued a share capital of £ 480,000. Further expansion was aided by the acquisition of a number of smaller local breweries in the early 1900s.

Beamish & Crawford remained a strong and independent brewery and survived both world wars and two serious economic depressions without major problems.
It became famous in Ireland and beyond for its tasty stout (which is superior to Guinness and Murphy's, but was always sold a little cheaper in order to keep the old ties with the dockers and other working men intact) and also for 'Beamish Red', a lovely sweetish high quality ale that is lately only available in Cork. (It is a favourite drink with the Cricketers of Cork County CC and still on tap at their pavilion on the Mardyke.)

In 1962 Beamish & Crawford came under foreign ownership, when it was purchased by the Canadian brewing firm Carling-O'Keefe Ltd.
Even though the new owners embarked on a modernisation programme at the brewery, the take-over meant the end of a 170-year tradition and it started a slow but steady process of decline.
In 1987 the brewing group Elders IXL purchased Canadian Breweries (incorporating Carling-O'Keefe) and eight years later they sold the Cork brewery to Scottish & Newcastle, brewers of the famous 'Newcastle Brown Ale', the favourite drink of north-east England.
For them Beamish & Crawford was always only a side-show, and thus there was not much new investment in modern technology.
In addition to their own products, Beamish & Crawford now brew or distribute also a number of internationally known brands of foreign beer. They hold the Irish franchises for Carling, Fosters, Kronenberg 1664 and Miller.

Earlier this year Scottish & Newcastle, already a very large company, was taken over by an even larger rival, the Dutch brewing giant Heineken International. And with that move Beamish joined its local rival Murphy's as one of the many minority beers in the ever growing portfolio of Heineken International.

The planned closure of the Beamish & Crawford plant in the city centre might well make some commercial sense for the managers and share holders of Heineken, but for the people of Cork and many others in Ireland it is a severe blow. It comes - to make things worse - at a time of severe recession, when every job is vital for a recovery.
By closing the historic brewery on South Main Street, Heineken is committing an act of cultural vandalism that shows ignorance for our Irish traditions and contempt for the people of Cork.

I have no power to stop this, even though I wish I had. And I am not even a great drinker of beer. But now and then - in the right company - I might have a few pints like almost everyone else here in Ireland.
I will make sure that from now on not a drop of Heineken will ever again pass my lips, as a personal act of protest against the ruthless cultural vandalism of Heineken International.

You might think that such a personal protest is futile and makes no difference to a giant like Heineken. And you are probably right.
But I will still do it, in the same way that I have not used any airline in more than 18 years, not been to any fast food outlet for more than 40 years, never use any products from Nestle and Kellogg's, and not buy anything made in the USA since George W. Bush occupied the White House unelected in 2001.
I do have my principles, and one of them is not to give any money to people and companies who abuse their political or commercial power. Heineken has just joined this group, and it is a sad development. They used to be a decent Dutch brewery, but that seems now a very long time ago.

The Emerald Islander

Cluster Bomb Convention signed in Oslo

An important landmark convention that bans the use of cluster bombs has been signed during a special ceremony in Oslo.

The Minister for Justice Dermot Ahern travelled to the Norwegian capital and signed the convention on behalf of Ireland.

Ireland is one of the - so far - 108 countries who support the international convention, which aims to prohibit the use of weapon systems that disperse large numbers of sub-munitions.

Dropped from aircraft or fired from artillery guns, cluster bombs explode in mid-air to randomly scatter hundreds of so-called 'bomblets', which are miniature mines and can be as small as 8 cm in size.

A certain percentage of the bombs do not explode on impact and remain a threat to soldiers and civilians alike, often long after a conflict has ended.
The small 'bomblets' are an even more serious menace, as they can remain undetected on or in the ground for a long time.

Thousands of civilians who live in former war zones have been killed or seriously wounded by them. Many of those injured are children, as cluster bombs are often mistaken for toys.

The campaign group Handicap International estimates that some 100,000 people have been killed or injured by cluster bombs since 1965.
A number of victims and relatives of the victims of cluster bombs travelled to Oslo as well, to support the treaty and to call for more countries to sign.

However, three of the world's largest producers and stockpilers of cluster munitions - the USA, Russia and China - still refuse to sign the convention.
So is Israel, which dropped more than a million bomblets on Lebanese cities in July and August 2006, an act of unprovoked and criminal aggression that has been condemned by the UN and many countries around the world, but keeps killing and wounding Lebanese civilians almost on a daily basis.

The convention to ban cluster munitions was debated and eventually agreed on during a twelve-day-long conference in May of this year in Dublin. (see my entry of May 19th)
It was the largest international event of its kind ever hosted by Ireland, and the deliberations received much media attention in Ireland and many other countries.

The convention to ban cluster munitions is a large step forward towards world peace, and one hopes that under the up-coming presidency of Barack Obama the USA will join the rest of the civilised world and sign the document as well.

The Emerald Islander

Cowen tours Europe in Search for a Solution to the Lisbon Treaty Deadlock

The Taoiseach has stated that he hopes "to find an acceptable way to break the deadlock over the Lisbon Treaty with his EU partners" ahead of a summit next week.

Brian Cowen (left) is mulling whether or not to call a second referendum on the Lisbon Treaty after its rejection by the Irish voters in June of this year.

"Working closely with my colleagues within the European Council, I'm hopeful that we can identify the elements of an acceptable way forward next week," Cowen said, referring to the EU summit in Brussels next Thursday and Friday.

Speaking in Berlin, he also said that "any resolution to the impasse must address not only the concerns of the Irish public about the charter".
"I'm very conscious that it must also be acceptable to colleague member states who have made clear their desire to see the reforms contained in the Lisbon Treaty enter into force as soon as possible," Cowen declared during a joint press briefing with the German Chancellor Angela Merkel.

Germany was the second stop on Cowen's mini-tour of European capitals to discuss the treaty. He will head to London today to meet Prime Minister Gordon Brown, and to Paris tomorrow for talks with President Nicolas Sarkozy, as France currently holds the rotating EU presidency.

Cowen's first destination yesterday was Luxembourg, where he met Prime Minister Jean-Claude Juncker (right), who - despite the small size of his country - is a very influential European politician and often seen as the éminence grise of the EU. The meeting took place behind closed doors, in an atmosphere of great secrecy, and no details about it have emerged.

Cowen is thought to be considering whether Irish voters would back the Lisbon Treaty in a new referendum, if guarantees were given on key concerns including abortion, corporate tax and the Republic of Ireland's cherished military neutrality.
Government researchers found that those issues, as well as opposition to losing the permanent Irish EU Commissioner in Brussels, were the main reasons for the rejection of the Lisbon Treaty by 53% of Ireland's voters on June 12th.

"The Taoiseach's discussions with his EU counterparts will focus on the situation in relation to the Lisbon Treaty ahead of next week's European Council," Cowen's office said today.
"Other EU issues, notably the climate change and energy package, and the international financial crisis, are also likely to feature."

In 2001 Irish voters rejected the EU's Nice Treaty, but the result was overturned the following year in a second referendum, when clarifying declarations were given by other member states. So Cowen hopes he can orchestrate another U-turn, if he brings the right kind of compromises home from Europe.

Though this calculation has a certain logic, there is a significant difference between then and now. In 2001 Taoiseach Bertie Ahern (left) enjoyed strong support from the Irish electorate, and the first Nice referendum was defeated narrowly, with a very low turnout of voters.

The Lisbon Treaty was rejected by a clear majority, and the turnout of voters was high. And - in contrast to 2001 - the popularity of the government, its main party Fianna Fáil and the Taoiseach himself are now at an all-time low.
So it is more than likely that the Irish electorate would reject the Lisbon Treaty again, should they be forced to vote in a second referendum, by a government that is now loathed throughout the country.

While Brian Cowen flew off to discuss the treaty with his EU counterparts, the opposition leader has pressed for private briefings from the Taoiseach.

Fine Gael leader Enda Kenny (right), whose party supported the treaty even stronger than Fianna Fáil, said that the issue was "a matter of national importance", and that Ireland was now "becoming the butt of some anti-European pressure".

"We need to know what it is that the government proposes to do when the Taoiseach goes out to Brussels next week, to explain to the other heads of government the strategy for Ireland," Enda Kenny demanded.

I am sure that he will be informed about those plans in time, but I doubt that it will help him and his party to be a more effective opposition against an ever more incompetent government.

The cross-party pact in support of the Lisbon Treaty has damaged the standing of both opposition parties that took part in it - Fine Gael and Labour - with a significant section of the Irish electorate.
In order to unseat and replace the current government, the opposition needs to be seen distant from Fianna Fáil and Brian Cowen, and not - once again - as his partners.

The Labour Party seems to have grasped that nettle. At their national conference in Kilkenny last weekend delegates still said that the Lisbon Treaty had "positive elements for the future of Europe", but they also stated clearly that "the decision of the Irish voters should be respected".

This is the right approach. The people have voted - fair and square - and made a decision. If every time a referendum brings a result the government does not like a second round of voting is forced on the nation, it is a clear affront to Democracy and to the people, who after all had a choice and made their decision.

In the current situation of crisis and great instability every Irish politician - regardless of party - should be aware of the public mood and show the electorate more respect. After all, it is the people who elect the TDs. And if they wish to remain TDs, they need to listen carefully to their voters and follow their will.

The Emerald Islander

Police Action against African Prostitutes and organised People Trafficking across Ireland

A total of ten people have been arrested yesterday in a major coordinated police operation, targeting people trafficking and prostitution across Ireland and Wales.

Four women and three men were taken into custody following coordinated Garda raids on nine brothels and six other locations across the Republic of Ireland. Another man was arrested by the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) in Newry, Co. Down, and a couple were detained by British police in Wales.

Those arrested in Wales are a 47-year-old Irishman and a 31-year-old woman from South Africa. The four women and three men being held in the Republic are suspected of committing a number of criminal offences, including organising and managing prostitution.

Brothels in Cavan, Drogheda (Co. Louth), Athlone and Mullingar (Co. Westmeath), Sligo, Kilkenny, Enniscorthy (Co. Wexford), Newbridge (Co. Kildare) and Waterford were raided and searched by officers of the Garda Síochána (Ireland's police).

Six other locations in Co. Carlow were also searched by Gardaí, including the homes and offices of a number of professional individuals, among them an unnamed accountant.

The raids followed an international investigation into organised people trafficking, which involved the Garda Síochána, the PSNI and the UK's Serious Organised Crime Agency (SOCA).

The PSNI said that the man arrested in Newry was being detained on suspicion of immigration offences.
It also conducted a number of covert inquiries at several locations throughout the North, which are being used as brothels by an criminal gang, organised through the internet.

A spokesman said the PSNI believes it has "dismantled an organised crime gang which was operating in three jurisdictions in Europe and has close links to South Africa".

03 December 2008

Broadband Operators con Millions in Ireland

Like a string of pearls one Irish scandal lines up neatly beside the next, and the next, and the next...
Today we had already the revelation that we pay a lot more for petrol and diesel than anyone else in the EU, but since there are so many scandals in Ireland, they now come out at the rate of two per day. So - here is the second for today:

New research shows that broadband subscribers in Ireland can rarely access the maximum connection speeds advertised by Internet service providers.

A study on broadband available in Dublin, Cork, Galway and Limerick has found that - on average - consumers with fixed lines benefit from just 60% of the advertised speeds, for which they pay a monthly fee.
This is like being charged for champagne, but being served a cheap third-rate sparkling wine from Italy.

The report by the Epitiro Internet monitoring firm has found that wireless and mobile users do slightly better, receiving on average about 64% of the bandwidth they pay for. But still, this is less than 2/3 of the service one has contracted and pays for.

A high-speed Internet connection helps web pages to load faster, makes it easier to download or view video content, and increases the potential for gaming or making telephone calls over the world-wide web.

The Epitiro results were compiled following over 5 million tests on the services offered by nine different companies.

Overall, Smart Telecom was deemed to be the best of the providers surveyed, followed by BT Ireland and Digiweb. And to no-one's surprise Eircom - Europe's worst and still most expensive telecommunications company - brings up the rear, carrying the red lantern.

Because the report only examined trends in urban areas, further tests are planned in 2009, to compare services on an urban to rural basis.

The authors of the report say that broadband users should be aware of their connection speed and chose their provider and subscription according to their needs.

There are easy ways to test one's one connection speed, and if one finds that the actual speed is significantly lower than the service one is billed for, a serious word with the service provider is advisable.

The Emerald Islander

Unemployment Rate in Ireland reaches 7.8%

The latest unemployment figures from the Central Statistics Office (CSO) show another record number of Irish people signing on to the Live Register in November.

16,900 people signed up for unemployment payments or Social Welfare credits last month. This brings the total to 277,200 - the highest level since September 1996.

In the year to November, the Live Register saw an unadjusted increase of 106,864 - a jump of 66.1%. This compares with an unadjusted increase of 94,502 or 60% in the year to October.

The figures released today show that another 13,600 men signed on the Live Register in November, reflecting the ever slowing construction industry. There was also an increase of 3,300 women.

The CSO says that the standardised unemployment rate in November rose to 7.8% from a rate of 7.4% in October.

We are living beyond our Means

Brian Lenihan (photo), our Minister for Finance, says that we are living beyond our means. And of course he is right.

In fact, we have been living well beyond our means for years now.
And we all were heavily encouraged to do so by his party, the government he is part of, and the whole orchestra of Irish banks, industry, retailers and media.

Only a few silly old-fashioned fools like me, for whom traditional values are still important, did not participate in the gigantic spending spree of the 'Celtic Tiger' years.

I was mocked for not going on two or three foreign holidays each year, and some people think I am 'dull' because I do not get drunk every weekend like many of my compatriots do.

I cannot remember how many times I was offered to buy a newly built apartment - "as an investment" - or to spend good money on some 'holiday home' in Bulgaria. There were offers to invest in a golf resort on the Algarve in Portugal, and when I told the man that I like Portugal, but hate golf, he looked at me like some child that has seen the real Santa Claus.

No, I did not fall for the bubble, as I could see for years that it would not last, the way Irish people were behaving and spending as if there was no tomorrow. Our banks encouraged us to do even more, offering ever more loans and credit cards, even to people with little or no regular income.

Until this summer I did receive at least one "pre-approved" offer of a new credit card in my e-mail each week. Sometimes there were more. Had I been a scoundrel, I could have taken them all, used them to their limit, and then just moved on. Some people have done that, and now they have no idea how to get on with their lives. They see debt counsellors and stress counsellors, and heaven knows how many other specialist counsellors for whom the taxpayers' foot the bill.
Some others simply emigrate and leave their financial millstones behind in Ireland. Well, in fact they put them around our necks, as we - those who remain here - will have to share the burden, no matter how large it is.

I like openness, and when a minister comes out and tells us the plain truth, straight to our face, I really appreciate it. So - thank you Brian Lenihan, thanks for telling us as it is.

The only little problem I have with it is that it was your predecessor (who is now the Taoiseach) and his great mentor Bertie - the 'cute fellow' - who told everyone to spend, spend, spend, as we "never had it so good".
It was your party Fianna Fáil that inherited the infant 'Celtic Tiger' in 1997 from the 'Rainbow coalition'. Instead of treating him well and feeding him carefully but modestly, you overfed him with greasy chips, bags of crisps and bags of sweets. Thus you created a monster that grew too fast and in the wrong way. And before you knew it, this monster devoured the economy, and then imploded.

So, Mr. Lenihan, I hope you don't mind me saying that you have quite some brass neck making such a statement. I presume you have heard the phrase about those sitting in glass houses, and what they should do - or better not do - with stones...

Yes, we are living beyond our means, at least most of us. And as a country we definitely do, thanks to eleven years of Fianna Fail in government. It is good that someone important has the guts to say it openly and in public. But now your government, Mr. Lenihan, and especially your department, should begin to give a good leading example we all can follow.
  • Stop wasting any more taxpayers' money on projects and things nobody wants and needs.
  • Cut the princely expenses accounts of ministers, TDs and senior civil servants.
  • Stop the lavish lifestyle your government got used to during the boom times.
  • Instruct the Revenue Commissioners to claw back the money that 'fat cats' like Rody Molloy took out of the taxpayers' coffer and used it on themselves while mixing with stars and millionaires in Florida.
This would be a start. And then you could cut all salaries of TDs, Senators, Ministers and that of the Taoiseach himself by 50%. That should give you a lot of extra money, plus a lot of popularity around the country.

You are right, we are living beyond our means as a nation, especially one with very few natural resources. But no-one in Ireland lives more beyond their means than our government.

By now you must know that we are a trusty lot, not too bright and not too critical. We followed you into the spending spree, and as you led the way, we even followed you into the recession.
Be sure we will follow you out of it again, if you know the way and go ahead as fine example.

You do know the way out of the crisis, I hope... If not, we can start thinking of eight songs, because then we are all doomed on a desert island.

The Emerald Islander

The Irish are ripped off at the Petrol Pumps

A new day, and another new Irish scandal - as I have predicted it last week.

According to Ireland's largest opposition party Fine Gael (FG), Irish people are paying significantly more for petrol and diesel than anyone else in the rest of the EU.

The party says that Irish motorists have to spend every month on average € 30 million more that they should, and it is not because of higher taxes.

In recent weeks the costs of petrol and diesel have dropped significantly, due to a drastic fall of the price for crude oil. But Fine Gael says that the prices Irish drivers have to pay at the petrol stations are not going down enough, as oil companies and petrol stations decide not to pass on the full benefit of price reductions and pocket the money themselves instead.

The party has been comparing the prices people in Ireland are paying to everyone else in the EU.

Fine Gael's deputy leader and Finance spokesman Richard Bruton (photo) explains that petrol is 24% more expensive in Ireland, while diesel costs 18% more than in the other 26 EU countries.

Once again we are ripped off in a shameless and criminal way by big businesses - in this case the oil and petrol companies - and no-one seems to be able to do anything about it.

The government does not care, as its members are driven around in their luxurious ministerial cars by Gardai and have not even a clue what Irish people pay on the petrol pumps.
And the National Consumer Agency - a toothless paper tiger established by Bertie Ahern to give his ex-girlfriend Celia Larkin a cosy little job - shows no interest in the matter either.

What - I wonder - will Irish people have to do before the complacent and lazy louts in government begin to take any notice of us, our needs and our misery?

Might some demonstrations do the job? Or will it have to be a revolution after all...?

The Emerald Islander

Revenue Commissioners recover € 24 Million

The latest list of Irish tax defaulters shows that 111 individuals and companies have made settlements with the Revenue Commissioners and paid them more than € 24 million in back taxes and penalties.

One building company, Condron Concrete from Tullamore, Co. Offaly (home county of Taoiseach Brian Cowen), has paid the Revenue Commissioners over € 8.1 million in owed tax, interest and penalties.

This is the largest recorded settlement since the Revenue Commissioners began to publish the names of tax defaulters.

However, it is only a drop in the ocean compared with a tax deficit of € 8 billion for 2008 (see yesterday's entry below) and the vast sums squandered by the senior management of FÁS out of their annual budget of € 1 billion.

As much as it is right for the Revenue Commissioners to go after tax dodgers in the private sector, it is a telling sign of double standards that wasters of large sums of taxpayers' money in the public sector are getting away with it. And if they are forced to resign - like Rody Molloy - they go home with their pockets full of good-bye money and will enjoy a princely pension for the rest of their lives.

This two-tier system with one law for the government and its minions, and another for the rest of us, needs to be abolished. One would hope that the Revenue Commissioners would support such an overdue move.

The Emerald Islander

02 December 2008

Ireland's Tax Deficit will exceed € 8 billion

Ireland's Minister for Finance Brian Lenihan (left) has said that he will take "remedial steps" to reduce government spending after the latest Exchequer figures revealed a very sharp deterioration in the country's public finances.

The new figures show that the shortfall for this year is now set to exceed € 8 billion, which is almost € 2 billion more than the government expected just two months ago.

November is the most important month in the tax collection calendar for the government, since it includes all self-assessed taxes as well as a larger proportion of corporation and capital gains taxes due for the year.

According to the new Exchequer figures there has been a massive shortfall of close to € 7.5 billion in the amount of taxes collected by the government during the first eleven months of the year.
This is a much more than was predicted, and analysts now expect the tax shortfall for 2008 to exceed € 8 billion, which is about twice as much as the amount allowed under EU guidelines.

Richard Bruton (right), the deputy leader and Finance spokesman of the opposition Fine Gael party, accused the government of "rushing the 2009 Budget" and of "making a bad economic situation much worse".

As a neutral observer and analyst I cannot help but agree with Deputy Bruton, who is regarded as one of Ireland's most capable experts on fiscal politics.

But what is even more significant is the fact that for years the Department of Finance - under Brian Cowen and now under Brian Lenihan - got every single forecast of taxation totally wrong. So-called 'experts' of the government and the highly paid senior civil servants in the department alike seem to have no clue about the real economic and fiscal situation in the country.

During the boom times they were each November "surprised" by a sudden surplus of several billions in extra taxes they had not expected to rake in. (But they saw well fit to waste them very quickly on needless projects and - more significantly - on themselves and their luxury lifestyle.) And now they are equally surprised that the shortfall is much larger than it was calculated only a few weeks ago.

One has to wonder what qualifications these people have to hold their senior positions. There are very few economists among them, but plenty of pig-headed apparatchiks whose inflexibility has cost the country already dearly - and it will get a lot worse next year.

No-one in the government, and especially in the Department of Finance, listened to the regular and steady warnings that some well-known and highly qualified Irish economists like David McWilliams, Senator Shane Ross and George Lee (of RTÉ) have issued over years. They predicted with amazing clarity everything that has happened during the past months of rapid economic decline, and I have contributed my own two-pence of analysis and advice as well.

It becomes ever more obvious that our current government, and in particular its majority party Fianna Fáil - which is in charge of the Department of Finance for more than eleven years now - is completely incompetent to govern the country.

Furthermore, the government is directly responsible for many of the elements that caused the current crisis.

But instead of doing the decent thing - resign and call a general election - the clueless and highly overpaid scoundrels muddle on and pretend that they understand what is going on.
Every day they cling on to their power - and the beloved perks it brings them - the situation for our country and economy will get worse. It is now time for the people of Ireland to take matters into their own hands, stand up and be counted.

People power has recently made a huge change in the USA, and people power has also just forced the corrupt government of Thailand to resign. We could learn a lot from those examples, and if we still care for ourselves and our future, we need to act now.

The Emerald Islander

SIPTU Members accept Aer Lingus Compromise

Members of Ireland's largest trade union SIPTU at Aer Lingus have voted to accept a compromise package of cost-cutting measures, aimed at saving the troubled Irish airline around € 24.5 million.

Almost 80% of the ground staff voted in favour of the proposals, which would see redundancies, lower pay and more efficient work practices. The turnout for the poll was also around 80%.

In total, the airline is seeking to reduce its staff costs by € 50 million. (for details see my entry of October 7th)

Cabin crew, which is represented by the IMPACT trade union, will announce the result of the vote on their reform package on Sunday.

Following talks at the Labour Relations Commission last month, SIPTU members were asked to consider a range of proposals put forward as an alternative to outsourcing more than 1000 jobs.

Meanwhile SIPTU's National Industrial Secretary Gerry McCormack said that he thought the latest bid to take over the company by Ryanair (see my earlier entry below) would have "little or no effect on the ballot, except to make members even more determined than ever to defend decent pay and conditions within the aviation sector".

McCormack said that given Ryanair's track record, he thought Ryanair CEO Michael O'Leary's claims about fleet expansion and job creation would carry little credibility.
Even if the claims were credible, the bid still raised the spectre of a monopoly position for "an airline not noted for its concern for the public".

He added that SIPTU would be calling on the Irish government and on EU Competition Commissioner Neelie Kroes "to ensure competition and strategic connectivity are preserved for the Irish people".

Aer Lingus rejects new Ryanair Take-Over Bid

The board of Aer Lingus has rejected a € 748 million offer by Ryanair to buy and take over their airline.
In a statement, the board strongly advised its shareholders to "take no action" in relation to the Ryanair offer.

An earlier take-over bid by Ryanair, issued more than two years ago, was also rejected and later blocked by the European Union as well.

On October 5th, 2006 - only days after Aer Lingus was floated on the stock market - Ryanair announced it had bought a 16% stake in Aer Lingus and was offering € 2.80 for each of the remaining shares.
After Aer Lingus rejected these advances, Ryanair declared a few hours later that it had raised its stake to 19.2%. The low-cost airline also said it had no problem with the Irish government keeping its 28.3% of shares.

It is no secret that Ryanair's CEO Michael O'Leary (right) has a dream. The maverick entrepreneur who changed the structure, character and costs of European air travel in a few years beyond recognition and forced many other airlines to adopt his concept at least in parts, wants to create a single powerful Irish airline, which could carry over 50 million passengers a year.

Ironically this is exactly the opposite of what he wanted - and did - when he established Ryanair, which was to break the monopoly of Aer Lingus. The new large airline he now envisages would in fact restore the monopoly situation Ryanair has broken.

After the rejection of the 2006 take-over bid, which was criticised by the Irish government and eventually banned on June 27th, 2007 by the EU Commission on competition grounds, some analysts believed that this was the end of it and Ryanair would be content with owning a significant portion of their rival's shares.

But they did not take into account the personality of Michael O'Leary. He is a man used to get what he wants. And when he has set his mind on something, he usually keeps at it like a terrier. Whenever there is a chance, he points out the "unique opportunity" to form a large, competitive and profitable Irish airline.

In a move that surprised most analysts and was announced to the Irish Stock Exchange in Dublin yesterday morning, Ryanair declared it was offering now € 1.40 per Aer Lingus share (exactly half of what they offered two years ago).

It already owns now 29.82% of the former state airline, having bought up more Aer Lingus shares steadily and quietly all the time.

Ryanair says it wants to "merge the two airlines into one strong Irish airline group under common ownership, similar to recent mergers in Europe such as Air France-KLM and Lufthansa-Swiss".
It points out that its proposal represents "a premium of about 28%" over the average closing price (€ 1.09) of an Aer Lingus share in November 2008.
In fact, it also represents an premium of about 25% over the closing price of € 1.12 of an Aer Lingus share on Friday.

Ryanair suggests that both airlines should operate as separate companies and keep their separate brands, but share and combine organisation and facilities (such as maintenance, catering etc.).

It says that if the offer is successful, it will double the size of the Aer Lingus short haul fleet from 33 to 66 aeroplanes over the next five years. And it also promises 1000 new jobs.

But still the board of Aer Lingus is having none of it. For them Michael O'Leary is what the Carthaginian General Hannibal was to the Senate of Rome: the arch enemy "ante portas" (at their gates).

Aer Lingus, previously a fully state-owned company, floated on the Dublin stock exchange only in 2006, after the Irish government had decided on a part-privatisation. Within days Ryanair began snapping up shares, before going public with its take-over interest.
Only outsiders and people who never heard of Michael O'Leary could have been surprised by that.

And O'Leary still keeps trying, now with new arguments. "The world has changed", he says, pointing out the various mergers of other airlines and dwelling gloomily on the recession and global financial crisis.

"Over the past two years, the trading environment for all European airlines has deteriorated dramatically as a result of high oil prices and the global recession," O'Leary states plainly. "And more than 30 airlines have failed this year alone."

He says that the airline has requested meetings with the Ministers for Finance and Transport (Brian Lenihan and Noel Dempsey), the board of Aer Lingus and the airline's ESOT trustees to discuss the latest move.

After the announcement Aer Lingus shares jumped over 16% to € 1.30 on the Dublin stock exchange, while Ryanair shares were down marginally.

As much as one might think that with the formal rejection from the Aer Lingus board this second attempt of Ryanair to swallow their rival has ended in failure, just like the first one more than two years ago, this is not necessarily so.
Michael O'Leary is a man with vision and long-term plans, and as long as there is even the slightest chance of success, he will not give up.

Take-over battles can be lengthy and costly, but Ryanair has deep pockets, filled with plenty of cash, which is becoming ever more scarce elsewhere. I am sure that O'Leary will continue to buy up as many Aer Lingus shares as he can get hold of. And the larger his stake in the company grows, the more likely it is that he might one day succeed with his take-over ambition.

With the Irish government finding itself in ever more financial trouble now, I would not rule out a deal in which Ryanair offers Finance Minister Brian Lenihan a nice lump sum for the 25.1% of Aer Lingus shares that are still in state ownership.
Michael O'Leary has long argued that it is "not the job of a goverment to run an airline". With an increase of the financial crisis and a decrease of government liquidity such an argument could suddenly find new supporters where there were none two years ago.

Only time will tell, but I would advise anyone - in government or private business - never to underestimate Michael O'Leary.

The Emerald Islander


P.S. In a separate development it has been reported that British Airways (BA) are in merger talks with Quantas, the main airline of Australia. If successful, this would create the world's third-largest airline.
In a statement BA says that a merger would be through the creation of a dual-listed company, listed in both London and Australia.
This follows indications from the Australian government that it may be prepared to relax the rules on foreign ownership. Under current Australian law, Qantas must be at least 51% Australian-owned and any individual foreign airline can only own up to 25% of it.

01 December 2008

Cowen puts his Hope and Trust in Coca Cola

Yesterday was a really bad day in Ireland.

We still have the most incompetent Irish government in living memory, and its performance is getting worse by the day. The country is in the grip of the most serious recession for decades, with unemployment rising faster than ever and its numbers reaching and surpassing those of the last recession we had. As if that were not enough, ever more scandals are uncovered. They appear almost faster and more often than overland buses.
And to make things even worse, it has been freezing cold, with temperatures below zero degrees Celsius for most of the day. (The Meteorological Office meanwhile announced that it was the coldest November day since 1985.)

Ireland's Sunday newspapers are usually a good indication of what is going on in the country and what is on people's minds.

There were of course numerous articles about the outrageous FÁS scandal. Its revelation - slice by slice - began a week ago with a large Sunday Independent article by the independent Senator Shane Ross (who happens to be also the paper's business editor).

The outrageous price hike for health insurance, which hit us on Friday and exposes the now uncontrolled greed of the insurance companies VHI and Quinn, also received much attention.

And then there was the latest bomb shell, revealed by the Sunday Tribune, that many of our pension schemes are in danger of collapsing, as Irish pension funds have apparently accumulated massive deficits of between € 20 and € 30 billion.
Since the report was based on a leaked internal memo from Mary Hanafin, the Minister for Social and Family Affairs, one has to take it very serious, even though she and the Taoiseach do not.

With the recession, the crisis and all the scandals and problems at his door, one would expect Brian Cowen to be very concerned and very busy, spending as much time as possible in his office and trying to sort out all the elements that make us ever more poorer and uncompetitive.
One would also expect him to keep a keen eye on the rising tide of violent crime and drug abuse in Ireland, a situation which worsened steadily over the past ten years. These were the years of previously unseen wealth and economic growth in Ireland, the years when Bertie Ahern was Taoiseach and ignored all the nasty sides and elements the boom brought along as well.
He did absolutely nothing about the spreading of ever more violent gangland crime, fuelled by the increasing drug habits of stupid Irish teenagers and even more stupid and irresponsible middle-class professionals who take drugs to spice up their dull lives or to cope with the stress of their jobs.
Brian Cowen was a senior Cabinet Minister for all these years, and now, that he has inherited the mantle of power from Bertie Ahern, he also does nothing about crime and violence on our streets.

No, our new Taoiseach has other priorities.

Instead of sorting out the country's many problems, he went down to Wexford yesterday, for an - as he sees it - very important event.

He took great pride in personally attending the official ground-breaking ceremony to mark the start of building work for a new Coca Cola 'flavouring plant', which will be established on a 41 acre site there, sponsored and supported by the IDA (Industrial Development Agency).
All smiling, as if the 'Celtic Tiger' were still alive, the Taoiseach and his entourage were anxious to point out that the new factory will "create 60 jobs in the area" and even "up to 100 jobs after five years".
Brian Cowen also praised Coca Cola for its "major investment of € 190 million in Ireland".

One really has to wonder on which planet Cowen is living these days! 60 new jobs - and perhaps another 40 in five years' time - are tiny drops in the vast ocean of the Irish labour force, where now 10,000 people are losing their jobs each month, thanks to his and his ministers' arrogant incompetence!
And what are € 190 million compared with € 20 or € 30 billion deficit in the pension funds, or the € 400 billion the government has pledged to save our rotten banks, who brought the trouble they are in on themselves?!
This really goes far beyond a bad joke. This is an insult for the whole Irish nation!

Not even to mention the fact that Coca Cola is producing nothing but fizzy sugary drinks, which are very unhealthy and at least partly responsible for the massive increase in people - and especially children - being overweight or even obese. Sugary drinks, like the ones made by the Coca Cola company, are also blamed by dentists for "serious damage to children's teeth".

This is a company the Taoiseach favours so much that he has to be personally present when the first piece of sod at the new building site is turned by a worker's spade.

It is the same company that had - until recently - a similar factory already in Ireland. That one was in Co. Louth, and it was closed by Coca Cola after the management was unable to come to an agreement with the local workforce. Coca Cola wanted a 'union-free shop', while the workers insisted that as free Irishmen they have the right to join a trade union. Neither side budged, so Coca Cola closed the plant in Louth and is now planning to build a new one in Wexford instead. (I wonder why... Aren't the people from Wexford nick-named the 'yellow bellies'...?)

Well, now that we know Brian Cowen's list of priorities, many things become a lot clearer. How could anyone even think of bothering him with the future of the country, when he has to turn a piece of sod for Coca Cola?

Surely, those 60 new jobs in Wexford will turn the tide for him, end the recession, bring the banks back into shape and make the people vote for the Lisbon Treaty in a second referendum.

It's all the power of Coca Cola, and Cowen obeys when he is called to come with a spade.
"Put your trust in Coca Cola," he says, "and all will be well again."

I just wonder what he might be thinking when he eventually wakes up, sees the country in tatters and the streets full of people, demonstrating against him and his silly little Coca Cola government...

The Emerald Islander

Irish Farmers "won't go away quietly"

Padraig Walshe (left), the President of the Irish Farmers Association (IFA), is warning the Irish government that "farmers won't go away quietly and accept the Budget cuts".

He was speaking yesterday evening in Ennis, Co. Clare, where more than 7000 IFA members from counties Clare, Cork, Galway, Kerry, Limerick, Offaly, Roscommon, Tipperary and Wexford had gathered for a mass demonstration to vent their anger.

Since October more than 20,000 Irish farmers have now expressed their anger over the 2009 Budget cuts at various IFA meetings all over the country. (see also my entries of November 2nd & 16th)

The IFA says that the recent cutbacks will mean a € 20 million loss to farmers in the region every year and is urging the government to think again.
It also accuses the Minister for Agriculture Brendan Smith to be "in denial over the impact of the government cuts on farmers".

Padraig Walshe says that Minister Smith is "disingenuous by referring to 2008 payments, which have nothing to do with the government's farm cuts for 2009".

"The way farmers have been hit is totally unacceptable", Walshe declared in an interview with RTÉ.
"The cuts are a direct attack on the viability of low-income farmers, especially in the West. Many farmers will not be able to make a living from farming under these conditions."

In reply, Brendan Smith (right) said that he did "not accept claims about the impact of the cuts on farm incomes".

This is another example of a Cabinet Minister closing his eyes and ignoring the facts, hoping that the problems will somehow 'go away'.

Smith, who was only appointed to his current position in May of this year when Brian Cowen became Taoiseach , seems to be quite a fast learner when it comes to collective ignorance and - as Padraig Walshe pointed out - denial.

He makes a fine addition to a Cabinet that is meanwhile so far removed from reality and from the Irish people that no argument, no matter how valid, can get through the ring of political cotton wool it surrounds itself with.

There are two ways to deal with this: Either the government removes the cotton wool, or the people have to remove the government. Personally I think the latter is the more desirable and more effective solution to improve our lives, our country and our economy.
As the IFA would be a welcome ally in such an operation, I hope that this time the farmers will indeed "not go away quietly" and remain strong and steadfast in their protest.

The Emerald Islander

30 November 2008

Now our Pensions are in Trouble as well...

Two days ago I wrote that a new scandal or outrage appears in Ireland now on a daily basis. Sadly, I have not been wrong and even Sundays are no longer free of bad news.

After the FÁS scandal dominated last week (see my entries of November 25th, 26th & 27th) and on Friday a 'double whammy' from the country's two largest health insurance companies hit us with immense and unaffordable increases in health insurance premiums (see my entry of November 28th), we are learning today that our pensions might be in serious trouble as well.

One cannot help wondering if there is actually anything left here in Ireland that is working well, functioning properly and in good order.

Taoiseach Brian Cowen (left) was quick to react this time and declared that the government would be "engaging the pension industry" to "review funding arrangements".

Once again he only gives us a few empty and meaningless words, despite the seriousness of the matter. What does it mean when the government is "engaging the pension industry"?
Should not the government be in regular contact with and in control of the 'pensions industry'?

(By the way, the use of the word 'industry' in this connection turns my stomach. An 'industry' produces things. Pension funds do not produce anything. They only administer money and shift it around in the hope to make profits, obviously not with much success lately.)

What will happen after the government has "reviewed funding arrangements"? And what exactly is a "funding arrangement" when it is at home?

If the Taoiseach thinks that he can bamboozle us with such hollow language, he is in error.

We demand to know what is really happening, when it is happening, and what the consequences are. And while we are at it, we also like to know why nothing has been done about the problem in the past.

Brian Cowen's empty statement today follows the leaking of a confidential report, which warns that a number of pension schemes "could collapse within the next six months, affecting tens of thousands of Irish workers".

The leaked internal report was prepared for the Cabinet by the Minister for Social and Family Affairs Mary Hanafin (right). So at least she seems to know what is going on.

A memo, seen and made public by Ireland's Sunday Tribune newspaper, warns that "defined-benefit schemes in the private sector and defined-contribution schemes could be under threat as the total pension deficit reaches between € 20 and € 30 billion".

The memo says that in defined contribution schemes, which are directly linked to investment returns and where a worker carries the investment risk, there is "anecdotal evidence that best practice is generally not applied", leaving people "exposed to more risk than they might realise".

"These are turbulent and difficult times for money markets, where most pension funds are invested," Mary Hanafin said in a statement today.
"Pension fund managers have yet to report on their funding standards to the Irish Pension Board, but in public comments they have indicated that funds are subject to market fluctuations."

She added that the government is "continuing to closely monitor the situation and is preparing proposals on the long term strategy on pensions, following the submissions made to the Green Paper on Pensions earlier this year".

Following the example of her master, Mary Hanafin is trying to keep us in the dark. How stupid does she think we are? Does she really believe we need to be told that "these are turbulent and difficult times for money markets"?
And what does it mean that "the government is continuing to closely monitor the situation"?

To 'monitor' something means a passive observation from a distance, in modern times usually via an electronic media screen, or monitor. So this is all the government does. Sitting there and watching numbers running over a computer screen.
No wonder that the country and our economy are in such a shambolic state!

Anyone can look at data on a computer. Even my cat is able to do it. And I am almost certain that she understands them better than our government does.

If incompetence and complacency would make people small, our present government would have a very comfortable existence beneath the floor carpets in Leinster House!


The Irish Business & Employers' Confederation (IBEC) has also repeated its recent expression of concern (see my entry of October 7th) that a number of private sector defined-benefit schemes are in danger and said "this situation could put companies themselves in danger".

Brendan McGinty (left), IBEC's Director of Industrial Relations and Human Resource Services, said he is "concerned that three out of every four providers of private sector defined-benefit schemes" would not be in a position "to meet total pension payments if they were required to do so tomorrow".
"This is the scenario which the government and pensions board use to determine a scheme's liquidity," McGinty explained.

Employers are increasingly seeing defined-benefit provision as a "bottomless pit", he added, stating that IBEC is "calling for the liability to the taxpayer from defined benefit pensions in the public sector to be capped" and urging the government and pensions board to take immediate action.

Meanwhile the Irish Congress of Trade Unions (ICTU) has called on the government to introduce a State-run mandatory pension scheme.

ICTU General Secretary David Begg (right) said that - given the current market difficulties - it is "almost inevitable that some of the schemes will be in trouble".
Begg also agrees with a recent IBEC suggestion that "funding standards for pension schemes may need to be relaxed".

Having lived in a number of different countries, I am familiar with different systems of government, economy and also pensions.
And it really puzzles me why Ireland has not established a State-controlled universal pensions system a long time ago. Why are we - after 86 years of independence - still copying everything Britain does, while there are much better options and models elsewhere that we could adopt?

In my entry of October 7th - titled "Irish Pensions System in Need of Reform" - I have written about this matter already. So I will not repeat all my points and arguments here and suggest you go to the archive and call up this entry, which includes a detailed plan Ireland could follow.

The Emerald Islander

29 November 2008

Farmers protest against Fianna Fáil in Co. Offaly

While more than 8000 teachers and parents protested in Donegal town today against cuts to the education budget (see my earlier entry below), the Irish Cattle and Sheep Farmers Association (ICSA) demonstrated outside the Tullamore Court Hotel in Tullamore, Co. Offaly, where Fianna Fáil were holding their National Councillors' Forum Annual Conference.

Around 200 Fianna Fáil county and city councillors from around the country gathered for this meeting and had to pass the gauntlet of the angry farmers, who displayed banners, placards and a small flock of miniature plastic models of cows and sheep in front of the conference hotel.

ICSA's angry protest was directed against recent cuts in the agricultural budget, and especially against a reduction of support schemes for small farms, which affects mostly people farming in the west and north-west of Ireland, where they raise cattle and sheep.

The Taoiseach, the Tánaiste and three other government ministers were addressing the Fianna Fáil meeting, and it has been reported that especially Brian Cowen gave "a rousing speech" to his party members.
This is probably quite necessary, as the current unpopularity of the Irish government worries many Fianna Fáil councillors, particularly in light of the up-coming local elections next year.

The Tánaiste and Minister for Enterprise, Trade & Employment Mary Coughlan, Transport Minister Noel Dempsey, Education Minister Batt O'Keeffe and Agriculture Minister Brendan Smith also addressed the meeting and then faced the councillors in a questions-and-answers session, especially over the details of the controversial 2009 Budget.

However, in their usual arrogant way neither the Taoiseach nor his ministers had any time for the protesting farmers and showed no concern for their problems. I am sure the farmers - and not only those who were present today in Tullamore - will remember this when they cast their votes in future.

The Emerald Islander

8000 protest in Donegal against Education Cuts

Today over 8000 people took part in a protest march in Donegal town against the government's cuts in the education budget. The protesters included teachers, parents and members of boards of management from schools across the north-west of Ireland and came mainly from counties Sligo, Leitrim and Donegal.

They outnumbered the 2500 inhabitants of Donegal town by more than 3:1, and a good number of local residents also joined the demonstration.

The gathering in Donegal was addressed by John Carr (right), General Secretary of the Irish National Teachers' Organisation (INTO).
Representatives of other teaching unions were also present.


INTO, which has already organised a number of protests around the country (see my entries of October 29th and November 22nd) since the 2009 Budget was introduced by Finance Minister Brian Lenihan on October 14th (see my entry of that day), is planning further demonstrations in the near future.

The largest of them is a national rally, which will be held in Dublin next Saturday.

INTO's courageous President Declan Kelleher (left) said that there is strong political support for the campaign, and from my own observations I can second this statement.

I would also urge anyone who has the time and opportunity to be in Dublin next Saturday to join the protest march. Education is the key to our future, and we should do everything in our power to prevent the damaging cuts the government has proposed for the education budget.

The Emerald Islander